03 / ARCHITECTURE DECISION MEMO
Who should control signing?
A delivery decision for a hypothetical bank launching treasury transfers with one asset, one network, and allowlisted counterparties.
Recommendation for the pilot
Evaluate provider-managed signing first, with the bank retaining transaction initiation, approval policy, reconciliation, and operational oversight. Proceed only if legal and security approve the custody arrangement and the bank can demonstrate recovery, audit access, and a workable exit. If the bank requires direct control of key material or the provider cannot meet those gates, evaluate bank-operated signing.
Decision 1 · Who runs the signing service?
| Question | Provider-managed signing | Bank-operated signing |
|---|---|---|
| Operating responsibility | Provider operates signing. Bank owns its authorizations and oversees the service. | Bank operates the signer and owns key lifecycle, recovery, staffing, and evidence. |
| Outage and recovery | Verify support coverage, escalation, visibility into request state, and recovery evidence. | Rehearse the bank’s recovery runbook and verify specialist coverage. |
| Exit and continuity | Review migration terms, withdrawal controls, and audit data export. | Verify recovery access, infrastructure dependencies, and supported asset migration paths. |
Decision 2 · How is a signature produced?
An HSM is a hardware security module that protects cryptographic material and performs cryptographic operations within a hardware boundary. MPC threshold signing distributes the operation across participants using shares, so the full key need not be reconstructed to sign. Hardware protection and threshold signing address different questions and may be combined in a specific design. Validate the actual deployment and recovery model with engineering and security. Ledger HSM example · NIST threshold cryptography
Business approval and signing are separate controls. Two treasury approvers can authorize a request while the signer remains offline. In a provider-managed model, the bank can retain its initiation and approval process while the provider operates cryptographic signing. Bitpanda institutional custody model
What I’d ask at the decision review
- Can we determine whether an interrupted request was signed or submitted before attempting recovery?
- Can we recover signing without overriding policy or relying on an untested manual step?
- Can treasury and audit reconcile an approval, signature event, network reference, and internal entry to the same request?